Screaming Eagle Charters Customer Reviews

Name: Screaming Eagle Charters
Brand: Screaming Eagle Charters
Rating: 5 (18 reviews)

100% would recommend

5/5

From 18
verified reviews

Jack AI Customer Experience Snapshot

Captain Herman Haddaway consistently delivers exceptional fishing results on the Chesapeake Bay, with customers regularly hitting their limits on striped bass and bluefish. His expertise shines when conditions get tough - he makes tactical adjustments to keep fish coming and knows exactly where to find productive spots. Multiple anglers report limiting out early and switching to catch-and-release, with some landing oversized fish that had to be returned. Herman provides top-notch gear and even goes the extra mile by filleting catches for guests. Customers consistently praise Herman's dedication to making every trip memorable, often extending charters beyond the scheduled time to ensure satisfaction. He's particularly excellent with children, providing patience and encouragement that creates lasting memories for young anglers. Many guests mention his punctuality, organization, and willingness to pick up customers when transportation becomes an issue. Repeat customers frequently choose Screaming Eagle Charters over other local options.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

Striped Bass

Bluefish

Limiting Out

Top-Notch Gear

Excellent With Kids

Extends Charters

Punctual

Repeat Customers

Photos from Real Customers

See all images

Book Your Next Trip With Us

All Reviews

Caleb Smith

September 14, 2025

Trip - Chesapeake Bay Extended Shared Striped Bass Fishing Trip on September 14, 2025

Very knowledgeable captain and first mate. We caught lots of fish. Captain even picked us up from our room when we couldn’t find a ride.

Was this helpful ?

Leah L

October 22, 2024

Trip - on October 22, 2024

Captain Haddaway and his first mate were punctual, organized, and easygoing—a great crew all around. They knew the local fishing spots well and worked hard to put us on the fish. Even though the bite was slower during our time of day (early mornings are definitely better), we still caught some nice ones—some keepers, some released. The weather was perfect, the ride was beautiful, and we made some wonderful memories on the Chesapeake Bay. Thanks for an awesome day on the water!

Was this helpful ?

John B

September 28, 2024

Trip - on September 28, 2024

I booked a morning charter with Captain Herman and his first mate Brendan, and it was an amazing day on the water. We got off to a fantastic start with three rockfish bites in the first 15 minutes. When the bite slowed down after about an hour, the crew made some tackle adjustments, and we spent the rest of the trip hauling in bluefish nonstop. I’ve been on plenty of charters in various locations, and it’s frustrating when the crew seems disengaged or unwilling to adapt to improve the experience. That’s not the case with these guys—Captain Herman and Brendan were enthusiastic, attentive, and dedicated to making the trip a success. I’d recommend Screaming Eagle Charters to anyone looking for a top-notch fishing adventure.

Was this helpful ?

Jenny M

May 4, 2024

Trip - on May 4, 2024

Captain Herman was very transparent about the potential challenges we might face. Despite the unfavorable weather, he worked hard to ensure our fishing trip was worthwhile. He made it happen, and we were able to experience new aspects of fishing. We thoroughly enjoyed the trip, and my spouse was also very pleased with the experience.

Was this helpful ?

Ryan B

October 9, 2023

Trip - on October 9, 2023

We caught plenty of fish and had a fantastic experience.

Was this helpful ?

Leah L

October 5, 2023

Trip - on October 5, 2023

Captain Herman and his first mate Brenden provided exceptional guidance on our fishing excursion. Their assistance and expertise led us to where the fish were biting, resulting in a successful trip. We highly recommend Screaming Eagle Charters to anyone seeking a memorable fishing experience. Thanks for the enjoyable trip!

Was this helpful ?

John D

September 2, 2023

Trip - on September 2, 2023

What an amazing day! The boat was stunning, and the crew provided wonderful conversation. The fishing experience exceeded expectations. I highly recommend this charter—it's definitely worth the investment. My grandson is already eager to return. A huge thank you to the crew for making our day so fantastic!

Was this helpful ?

Emily

August 15, 2023

Trip - on August 15, 2023

If you want an outstanding fishing adventure in Maryland, Captain Herman is the man to see. He goes the extra mile to ensure you have an incredible time on the water.

Was this helpful ?

Kim P

July 8, 2023

Trip - on July 8, 2023

I had an amazing experience aboard the Screaming Eagle today! It was my first time on a fishing boat, and I couldn't have asked for a better captain and first mate. The group was fantastic, and we caught plenty of fish, making it an unforgettable trip. Plus, enjoying fresh fish at home afterward was the perfect ending. If you're looking for a great time out on the water, look no further – book your trip right here!

Was this helpful ?

Benjamin

June 5, 2023

Trip - on June 5, 2023

Our trip with Captain Herman exceeded all our expectations. He made sure we had a blast and brought home some delicious fish. 10/10!

Was this helpful ?

Olivia

March 1, 2023

Trip - on March 1, 2023

Captain Herman Haddaway's charter is the real deal. He's professional, friendly, and his knowledge of the bay is unmatched. We couldn't have asked for a better experience.

Was this helpful ?

Samuel

December 13, 2022

Trip - on December 13, 2022

We had an unforgettable day fishing with Captain Herman. He's not just a captain; he's a true angler at heart. He'll make sure you have an incredible time.

Was this helpful ?

Reel in Adventure, Explore Chesapeake Bay on Our Fishing Trips!

Chesapeake Bay Charter Reviews – What Our Guests Are Saying

At Screaming Eagle Charters, our Chesapeake Bay charter reviews speak for themselves. Guests frequently highlight the unforgettable fishing experiences they’ve had on the Choptank River, from reeling in trophy-sized Striped Bass to enjoying a smooth, well-organized day on the water. Many customers return year after year, praising Captain Herman Haddaway’s deep local knowledge, patient guidance, and expert trolling techniques. Whether it's a family outing, first-time angler trip, or a seasoned fisherman targeting rockfish, our customer testimonials consistently reflect memorable moments and high satisfaction.

Fishing the Chesapeake Bay isn’t just about the catch—it’s about the full experience. From calm morning departures to exciting hook-ups and scenic river views, visitors often mention how relaxed, fun, and successful their day turned out. With so many positive reviews about our Chesapeake Bay guided fishing trips, Choptank River charter boat experiences, and inshore rockfish adventures, it’s easy to see why new anglers feel confident booking with us. If you're looking for a trusted Maryland fishing guide who delivers results and great memories, our happy guests say it all.